There are several materials available today for sheet metal fabrication projects, meeting various specifications and needs. Among these materials, steel remains one of the most sought-after options for many applications. However, the decision between galvanized vs galvannealed steel remains a tough decision, even among experts. 

Galvanized and galvannealed steels are known for their strength, corrosion resistance, and durability, making them crucial in numerous industrial products. However, they differ in composition, properties, and applications. Choosing between them requires understanding their processes, similarities, and differences to make an informed decision for different project needs.

galvanized vs galvannealed steel
galvanized vs galvannealed steel

This detailed guide offers a complete breakdown of the differences between galvanized and galvannealed steel. Here, you will understand the different coating processes, their impacts on the steel materials, and how you can make the right choice for your unique applications. 

What Is Galvanized Steel?

Galvanized steel typically begins as low-carbon steel, which is then coated with zinc. This combination harnesses steel’s strength and zinc’s corrosion resistance, resulting in an economical, adaptable, and robust metal. Hot-dip galvanizing is the most prevalent method, involving immersing steel in molten zinc to create a protective layer. 

galvanized steel material
galvanized steel material

The process begins with raw steel, which is susceptible to corrosion due to its high iron content. During galvanization, the steel is immersed in a 850°F liquid zinc solution. Excess zinc is removed using air knives to achieve the desired coating thickness. The resulting molecular bond between zinc and steel on the exterior acts as a barrier, preventing and minimizing rust formation.

Alternatively, steel components can undergo galvanization after fabrication, using methods like electroplating. Galvanized steel displays a shiny, silvery-gray appearance with a characteristic spangle pattern of small, shiny specks, boasting a smooth texture.

Advantages of Galvanized Steel

  • Galvanized steel offers multiple advantages over standard and other treated steels:
  • It demands no extra maintenance or treatment throughout its lifespan.
  • It boasts high corrosion resistance thanks to the zinc coating, making it ideal for outdoor exposure and continuous water contact.
  • In comparison to other treated steels, galvanized steel is relatively inexpensive to manufacture.
  • By merging steel’s strength with zinc’s rust resistance, this steel enjoys a significantly extended lifespan compared to regular steel.

Disadvantages of Galvanized Steel

Galvanized steel, while advantageous, also presents some drawbacks when compared to other treated steels:

  • It contains zinc, which may leach out and release toxins into the environment.
  • The galvanizing process hardens the metal, rendering it less suitable for applications that need flexibility.
  • The zinc layer on galvanized steel can chip and crack, revealing the metal beneath. This is most common during production, potentially reducing the material’s corrosion resistance and leading to unattractive spots.
  • Adding a zinc coating makes the metal heavier.

What Is Galvannealed Steel?

Galvannealed steel undergoes a two-step process: first, it is galvanized, and then it undergoes annealing. During galvanization, a zinc coating is applied to the steel, followed by annealing while the zinc is still liquid. In this step, some iron dissolves into the molten zinc, forming a zinc-iron alloy on the steel surface, with approximately 90% zinc and 10% iron. This alloy creates a harder and more brittle coating compared to standard galvanized steel. This increase in iron content on the surface makes the material less prone to damage, while also improving its paintability as a secondary benefit.

galvannealed steel
galvannealed steel

The appearance of galvannealed steel is characterized by a gray, matte finish, which is generally considered visually appealing. Its surface is slightly rougher than untreated or freshly galvanized steel, though the degree of roughness varies depending on the manufacturing process. The grain structure of galvannealed steel is visible upon close inspection but remains subtle. Its coating facilitates good paint adhesion, often leading to additional coating or paint applications on galvannealed steel products.

Advantages of Galvannealed Steel

  • This steel material offers several benefits, including:
  • It is highly ductile, allowing it to be easily shaped into various forms.
  • Its zinc-iron alloy coating grants it superior corrosion resistance.
  • It has better weldability than galvanized steel because of the iron in the coating.
  • The iron in the coating enhances the steel’s hardness and resilience, making it less susceptible to chipping and scratching.
  • The slightly rough surface of galvannealed steel improves paint adhesion, leading to superior paint finishes.

Disadvantages of Galvannealed Steel

Galvannealed steel also comes with some drawbacks:

  • Its corrosion resistance isn’t as robust as that of galvanized steel, often necessitating paint for added protection against rust.
  • While the galvannealing process gives the steel a harder surface, this increased hardness can lead to brittleness, restricting its use in applications needing flexibility.
  • Its production involves not only the steps required for making galvanized steel but an additional annealing process as well, raising its sheet metal fabrication costs.
  • Like galvanized steel, its coatings include zinc, which has the potential to release toxins into the environment.

Key Differences Between Galvanized and Galvannealed Steel

To settle the galvanized steel vs galvannealed steel debate, let’s take a deeper look into their major differences.

Coating Composition

Galvanized steel features a sleek, polished zinc layer, occasionally including a small amount of iron, akin to what’s found in stainless steel. This coating’s weight is specified in ounces per square foot. It typically varies from 0.30 oz/ft² (G30) to 2.35 oz/ft² (G235).

On the other hand, galvannealed steel is coated with a zinc-iron alloy, presenting a matte appearance. This coating, known for its excellent quality, includes three distinct layers (gamma, delta, and zeta). It is measured in thickness from 0.40 oz/ft² (A40) to 0.60 oz/ft² (A60). Additionally, this type of steel is annealed post-coating to enhance its properties.

Coating Thickness

The durability of coated steels, such as galvanized and galvannealed steels, hinges on the qualities of both the coating and the base steel. Galvanized steel is coated with zinc, enhancing its resistance to corrosion. Although its surface is hard, it’s susceptible to chipping and scratches.

Galvannealed steel, in contrast, features a zinc-iron alloy coating that’s tougher than galvanized steel’s. Thus, it offers better protection against surface damage like chipping and scratching. Nonetheless, the surface robustness of galvannealed steel surpasses that of galvanized steel. However, the overall structural integrity of either type depends on the coating’s thickness and the base steel’s characteristics.

Corrosion Resistance

Both galvanized and galvannealed steels are covered in a zinc layer to fight rust and corrosion. They’re both great options for durable, long-lasting metal. However, Galvanized steel boasts a thicker zinc coating compared to the zinc-iron alloy coating of galvannealed steel. Therefore, it is significantly more resistant to rust. Thus, for demanding applications prioritizing rust resistance, galvanized steel proves more appropriate than galvannealed steel.

Galvannealed steel goes through an extra step where the zinc coating is heated, creating a zinc-iron alloy layer. This alloy offers very good corrosion resistance, but the layer itself is thinner than galvanized steel’s zinc coating. So, while still resistant to rust, galvanized steel takes the crown in this category.

Weldability 

Both steels are weldable, but galvannealed steel generally exhibits superior weldability compared to galvanized steel. Galvanized steel, coated with zinc, releases toxic zinc oxide fumes during welding, requiring proper ventilation and protective gear. Welding galvanized steel can lead to issues like cracks, excessive spatter, and incomplete fusion. It is usually recommended to weld steel parts before galvanization rather than afterward. 

galvanized steel welding
galvanized steel welding

Galvannealed steel, featuring a zinc-iron alloy coating, offers improved weldability due to the presence of iron. It emits fewer fumes during welding compared to galvanized steel, but precautions such as ventilation and protective equipment are still necessary.

Surface Appearance

Galvanized steel has a shiny, spangled appearance, a result of the zinc coating crystallizing through the galvanization process. Its surface, generally smooth and even, shines with a silver hue that varies from matte gray to glossy. The visibility of the spangle pattern can increase with the zinc coating’s thickness. It is a common sight in objects like HVAC ducting and highway guardrails. Its industrial aesthetic, marked by a unique spangle on each piece, makes it a popular choice for projects requiring an unpainted, metallic finish.

In contrast, galvannealed steel displays a muted, matte gray look, a direct outcome of the annealing process that occurs after galvanization. During annealing, the zinc coating interacts with the steel’s iron, forming an iron-zinc alloy layer that gives galvannealed steel its distinct finish. It offers an appealing surface that’s particularly paint-friendly due to the absorbent nature of its zinc coating. It is favored in the architectural field and the automotive industry for its aesthetic qualities and ease of painting.

Applications of Galvanized vs Galvannealed Steel

While these exciting sheet metal materials are valuable options in an extensive range of applications, they are more suited to certain ones than others. Let’s take a look at their specific applications. 

Applications of Galvanized Steel

Galvanized steel is widely favored in various industries for its resilience in outdoor and corrosive settings. Key uses include:

  • Industrial Uses: In industrial contexts, galvanized steel is a go-to material for creating  piping, storage tanks, and essential machinery for extracting oil and gas, thanks to its durability and resistance to harsh conditions.
  • HVAC Systems: Manufacturers of heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems frequently opt for galvanized steel due to its cost-effectiveness, longevity, and corrosion resistance. This makes it an excellent choice for ductwork that distributes air throughout buildings.
  • Agriculture: In the agricultural sector, galvanized steel is preferred for equipment production because of its resistance to rust and corrosion. Tools and machinery exposed to the elements benefit from the protective qualities of galvanized steel, ensuring durability over time.
applications of galvanized steel
applications of galvanized steel

Applications of Galvannealed Steel 

Galvanneal steel finds frequent use in indoor applications that demand superior paint adhesion and formability. These include:

  • Appliance Manufacturing: Galvanneal steel is a staple in producing a range of appliances like refrigerators, dryers, washing machines, and ovens. Its exceptional formability and resistance to corrosion make it ideal for fabricating parts such as frames, panels, and structural elements.
  • Electrical Systems: Galvanneal steel stands out for making conduits, junction boxes, and enclosures in electrical systems. Its formability and corrosion resistance are essential for these components, while its paintability allows customization to match the surrounding environment.
  • Automotive Industry: Automobile manufacturers rely on galvanneal steel to craft body panels, chassis components, and other structural parts. Its notable formability, corrosion resistance, and ease of paint application ensure a high-quality finish.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Galvanized and Galvannealed Steel

Choosing between these sheet metal materials depends on what your project needs most. That’s why you must consider the following factors:

Project Requirements

If preventing rust is your absolute priority, especially for outdoor projects exposed to the elements, then galvanized steel is your best bet. It is a good choice for things like gutters, roofing, or fence posts. However, if you plan to paint the metal, galvanized steel can be tricky. The zinc coating can make paint adhesion difficult. 

Here’s where galvannealed steel shines. The zinc-iron alloy layer it has creates a better surface for paint to stick to. So, if you need both corrosion resistance and a painted finish, galvannealed steel might be the better option. It’s commonly used for appliances, HVAC ducts, or metal furniture.

Environmental Conditions

For harsh outdoor environments that see a lot of rain, snow, or salt (like near the ocean), galvanized steel provides superior protection against rust and corrosion. This makes it ideal for things for outdoor structures.

Galvannealed steel, however, might be sufficient for milder environments. While its zinc-iron alloy offers good corrosion resistance, it’s not quite as heavy-duty as galvanized steel’s zinc layer. However, galvannealed steel can perform well indoors or in more sheltered outdoor areas. 

Remember, the key is to choose the level of corrosion resistance your project’s environment demands. For harsher conditions, galvanized steel’s extra defense is better. For milder environments or where aesthetics are important, galvannealed steel can be a good alternative.

Cost

When it comes to cost, galvanized steel is generally cheaper than galvannealed steel. This is because galvanized steel requires a simpler manufacturing process. However, don’t just pick based on price tag alone. Consider your project’s overall needs. If you need to save money and your project prioritizes basic rust protection in a mild environment, then galvanized steel might be the way to go.

But remember, galvanized steel can be trickier to paint due to its zinc coating. If painting is necessary, you might end up spending more on additional prep work or specialized paint. In such cases, even though galvannealed steel has a higher upfront cost, its better paintability could save money in the long run.

Ultimately, factor in both the initial cost of the steel and any potential additional expenses due to painting or the need for stronger corrosion resistance when making your final decision.

Availability

In terms of availability, both galvanized and galvannealed steel are generally widely available from metal suppliers and distributors. They come in various shapes like sheets, coils, and tubes, catering to a range of projects.

However, there might be slight differences depending on your specific needs. Galvanized steel, due to its longer history and wider use, might be more readily available in a broader range of thicknesses and sizes. For common applications, finding galvanized steel in the right size shouldn’t be an issue.

Galvannealed steel, while still common, might have slightly less availability, especially for very specific sizes or thicknesses. If you have a unique project requiring a less common dimension, you might need to check with a few suppliers or wait for a special order.

Conclusion

Galvannealed and galvanized steels are two essential options in sheet metal fabrication. These materials offer a unique range of properties that make them useful for several applications. However, choosing between galvannealed vs galvanized steel can be challenging due to their unique differences. While this article provided insight into both materials, expert guidance may be necessary for your selection. The ideal choice depends on your product’s specific requirements.For professional assistance in determining the ideal steel type for your project, trust Zintilon. At Zintilon, our experienced team in sheet metal fabrication can assist you in choosing between galvanneal and galvanized steel. Alongside guidance, we offer professional sheet metal fabrication services worldwide, producing prototypes and parts to meet high-quality standards efficiently. Moreover, we ensure cost-effectiveness and fast lead times in all our production runs. Contact us today, and let’s get your project underway!

Let's Start A New Project Today
Index
X